Friday, January 27, 2012
Cole Frederick CAPS #1
Lauren Bayne CAPS Blog #1
Third Culture Kids
A third culture kid, or global nomad, is a person that grew up in many different cultural contexts because his or her parents moved from their home country (Martin & Nakayama, 2009). The term is used because TCKs combine aspects of their birth culture and of the new culture in which they are immersed to create their own unique “third” culture. In this way, they develop a unique sense of identity that gives many of them the ability to understand and communicate easily with people from various cultures and backgrounds.
A friend of mine spent four years, ages eight through twelve, growing up in Bulgaria because her father was a missionary there. Her whole family relocated with him, including her mother, and older brother and sister. They lived in the capital, Sofia, where she attended a public school for a time, but later transferred to a U.S. Embassy school due to the poor public education. She became integrated in the culture of Sofia, even going so far as being friends with a son of the local Bulgarian mafia leader. She played soccer and baseball with the local “boys,” grew up calling her parents’ close Bulgarian friends “Uncles” and “Aunts,” and spoke both Bulgarian and English. Still today, six years after moving back to the United States, she refers to Sofia as home. The food, the sense of community, and even the dirty streets and rather provocative billboards on the streets of Bulgaria, integrated themselves with her white American identity, which transformed into her identity as a third culture kid. With this experience, my friend has acquired a passion for being involved internationally and has developed a resilience and understanding of cultures. But she has also acquired a feeling of being fragmented and marginalized. She has discovered that very few people understand, or want to understand, her experiences in Bulgaria. This leaves her discouraged, and now she does not mention Bulgaria in public unless she is asked about it.
Understanding part of the cultural identity of a third culture kid will greatly aid in any intercultural communication a person may have with one. This contact could prove to be one of the most unique intercultural communications a person can have because a TCK has a multicultural identity, something that many native-born, white Americans do not have. According to Dr. Ruth Useem, the sociologist who coined the term, third culture kids, “there is a high level of international activity in adult TCKs” (Cottrell, 1993). As I will likely work in an international setting in the future, having a basic understanding of one facet of a TCK’s identity will ease the process of intercultural communication and will open up the opportunity for me to learn more fully about his or her own unique cultural identity.
References:
Martin, J. N., & Nakayama, T. K. (2009). Intercultural Communication in Contexts. McGraw-Hill Higher Education.
Cottrell, Ann. (1993). ATCKs Have Problems Relating to Their Own Ethnic Groups. Retrieved from http://www.tckworld.com/useem/art4.html
Hofstede's value Orientations
Figure 1: Results from Hofstede's original study |
This topic is very interesting as it is a very dynamic observation about different cultures and is likely highly affected by location. The original study was done in only IBM branches, which brings a sampling bias into the study. That sampling bias would probably only affect judgments created about a sub group of people working in an IBM branch and would not affect the cultural value theory that was created. The results of the study primarily affect how one should be aware of cultural differences. It could be a poor decision to talk with somebody about what your culture considers an important masculine value if the other person's culture led them to believe that the solution would be more of a feminine value. This might not create angst but most likely produce some sort of confusion or reevaluation and require clarification. An example of this could be if you were to mention gender equality (labeled feminine) to somebody that believed in strong gender roles (labeled masculine).
I have personally not had a great number of interactions between opposite sides of the cultural difference. Recently, however, I was talking with my academic adviser (in the college of engineering). We were talking about life goals and he mentioned that he had always wanted to get a Masters in Business Administration and how it would have been ideal to work towards while (or shortly after) he earned his Ph.D, especially since he was going to school in Chicago. He then continued to say that he felt as if it were too late now because he is very busy with research and classes, his wife is pregnant, and once he turns 40 he will have to start preparing to die. While this was all said in a very lighthearted manner, it made me think about how different this man's life was to mine. We have relatively similar academic and personal goals, but he had spent his childhood and created his foundation for his life in the country Jordan, and was raised in a Muslim household while I have never lived for an extended period outside of Nebraska, and have not had any formal religious education.
Studying Hofstede's theory of cultural differences will probably make me take a closer look at how people are raised and try to connect that to their actions: even if they were raised in just different parts of the United States, Nebraska, Omaha, or even the same school district I grew up in. Most likely anything can be the cause of a persons belief as a collectivist or an individualist, and it seems important that these values are not overlooked or underestimated. Finally, while considering the cultural differences described by Hofstede's theory, I found an interview with Geert Hofstede himself, talking about a 6th cultural dimension.
References
Hofstede, G. (2012, January 05). Professor emeritus - geert hofstede. Retrieved from http://geert-
hofstede.com/index.php
Kanzler, S. (2010). Knowledge sharing in heterogeneous collaborations - a longitudinal investigation of a
cross cultural research collaboration in nanoscience.Journal of Business Chemistry, 2010(1), 111.
Retrieved from http://www.businesschemistry.org/article/?article=111
Martin, J. N., & Nakayama, T. K. (2009). Intercultural Communication in Contexts. McGraw-Hill
Higher Education.
Ethnic Identity - Michael Filipowski
Works Cited:
Maritn, J. N., & Nakayama, T. K. (2010). Intercultural Communication in Contexts (Fifth ed., pg. 185). New York, NY: Mcgraw-Hill.
Andrew Steinhoff CAPs #1
Personal Identity- Weiting Yue
Ethnic Identity by Nolan DeBord
An example of ethnic identity in today’s America is that of Judaism. Jewish people have some of the strongest traditions that live in today’s society. From an early age Jewish parents are usually strong in upholding the traditions such as going to Temple on the sacred day and celebrating Hanukkah. Not only do they celebrate those traditions but on the 13th birthday for a boy they will celebrate his bar mitzvah and for a girl her bat mitzvah. This tradition represents the transformation into manhood or womanhood. This is similar to the quinceanera for Hispanic girls on their 15th birthday.
Thursday, January 26, 2012
CAPS Blog #1
CAPS BLOG #1- Jihyun Kim
Fadhilah Lokman - CAPs Blog 1
Whitney Scholtes- CAPs Blog #1
Gender identity is a social and cultural identity in which notions masculinity and femininity. You can also say it is an identity in which what is means to be a man or a woman. It goes beyond biological sex or sexual identity. Culture and our society greatly influence our gender identity. From the time we are born we adopt a gender identity. Biologically, you may be a male or female, but with gender identity you are considered either a boy or a girl. Along with this, baby gifts may be blue to signify it's a boy and pink signifying it's a girl. As we get older our gender identity may become more prevalent. Culture and society may project that some activities are more masculine or more feminine. Some examples are hunting, watching football, and riding a motorcycle (which would be more masculine) and sewing, cooking, and watching soap operas (which would be more feminine). Masculinity and femininity change continuously and my be different between different cultures. For example there is a trend in the U.S. for woman to have very full lips but in Japan this is not considered attractive. Not all women have naturally full lips either, but we have the option to get fuller lips by injections or surgery. Thus, gender identity also gives us a sense of who we want to be and not only who we think we are. Culture and society gives us many images and definitions of what masculinity and femininity is supposed to be or what it is supposed to look like. Although we all don't seek to be the same, we do communicate our gender identity as part of who we are.
I am going to use myself as an example for this identity. I would identify myself with femininity mostly because I am a girl. When I was born, my mother smothered me in pink. As I grew older, I started to sew which would be considered more feminine. I did other activities associating myself with femininity like cooking, piercing my ears, and playing with girl dollies because they were more like me. I also avoided specific activities because I thought they were more for boys. I never played football, never went hunting, and never rode a skateboard because they were more masculine. I also have seen how society can affect and change gender identity. As I grew older, I played football a few times without changing my mind about my gender identity. I started to see boys with their ears pierced and it was socially acceptable. There are many examples throughout my life in which associate to gender identity and I could go on and on about them, but those are a few to give you an idea of how gender identity have been in my life.
The concept of gender identity has made me think of how it's influenced my life in the past and how it applies to my life now. It also made me think of how gender identity has changed and stayed the same throughout generations and decades. I also realize that gender identities have been affected and still will be affected by culture and society in the future. This concept has changed my mind in which we are more than just a biological sex. We are more than just male or female and gender identity affects us in more ways than I had assumed.
Heidi Krueger- Spiritual Identity
Worldwide Religious Affiliation
(Religion is not all of spiritual identity but it is one that plays a role in someone's spiritual identity.)
Archer and Waterman’s (1993) Assessment of Spiritual Identity Stage, Paraphrased by Griffith and Griggs (2001, p. 21)
Resources:
Archer and Waterman’s (1993) Assessment of Spiritual Identity Stage, Paraphrased by Griffith and Griggs (2001, p. 21)